Gnista and Claude Island,
side by side.
Price, agents, answering from the notch, terminals and privacy: what each does, and what Gnista adds.
Checked
Gnista or Claude Island: which should you pick?
Pick Gnista if you run more than Claude Code.
Claude Island is a free, open-source (Apache 2.0) menu bar app for Claude Code only.
Side by side
| Compared | Gnista | Claude Island |
|---|---|---|
| Price | €19 once, VAT included, for one named person. A year of updates included; €9 for each year more, if you want them, and the app keeps working without. Team plans for 5, 10 or 25 Macs. | Free and open source, Apache 2.0. |
| Agents | Gnista ahead28 agents have a page. 12 can be answered from the notch; the rest show when they need you, or when they are working and done. | Claude Code CLI only. |
| Answering | Gnista aheadAllow, Always, or Deny with a reason the agent reads; the diff with line numbers; plans; multiple-choice questions; replies. | “Approve or deny tool executions directly from the notch.” |
| Jumping | The exact tab or pane in Terminal, iTerm2, Ghostty, tmux, kitty, WezTerm, Warp, cmux, Zellij, Orca and Superset, and in the terminals of VS Code, Cursor and other editors. | Not stated on its page. |
| Macs | macOS 15 or later, Apple silicon and Intel. | macOS 15.6 or later. |
When Gnista is the better pick
- You run more than Claude Code: 28 agents have a page here, 12 of them answerable from the notch.
- You want plans, questions, replies and usage limits, and to jump to the exact terminal tab.
- You want a supported product with a trial and team plans.
Where the facts come from
More comparisons.
Gnista vs Vibe Island
Vibe Island is the closest app to Gnista: paid, one-time, made for many agents, with approvals and terminal jumping. They differ in price, trial, languages, the agents each lists and how much you can answer from the notch.
Gnista vs AgentPeek
AgentPeek is a paid notch and menu bar app for Apple silicon Macs, with usage tracking and dev server management next to its approvals.
Gnista vs AgentNotch
This is the paid AgentNotch at agentnotch.app. A free app at agentnotch.com and an open-source project on GitHub share the name; they are different products.
Gnista vs Crew Tower
Crew Tower is a paid, one-time notch app for 26 agents, with approvals, plans and an optional way to send a finished Claude Code session its next prompt.
Gnista vs Runnock
Runnock is a paid, one-time notch app for nine agents. It needs macOS 26 and Apple silicon.
Gnista vs Pushary Isle
Pushary Isle is the notch part of Pushary, a service that syncs agent approvals to your phone and other devices. It is a subscription and needs a Pushary account.
Gnista vs Open Island
Open Island is free and open source (GPL-3.0), with no server, telemetry or account. Its README says it is separate from the closed-source Vibe Island.
Gnista vs CodeIsland
CodeIsland is an open-source (MIT) notch app that says it supports 30-plus coding tools, with a free iPhone and Apple Watch companion.
Gnista vs Notchi
Notchi is a free, open-source (GPL-3.0) companion for Claude Code and Codex that lives in the notch of a MacBook.
Gnista vs Coucou
Coucou is a notch companion with a Mochi character. Its code is MIT; its name, character, icon and sounds are copyrighted. It also ships for Windows, Linux and Android.
Gnista vs Chimlo
Chimlo is a young, free, open-source (GPL-3.0) notch app for Codex and Claude Code. Its first public release is v0.1.0.