Notch apps for coding agents,
compared honestly.
Several Mac apps now show your coding agents in the notch. Gnista is built for people who run several agents and want to answer them without leaving their work. Here is how it compares.
Checked
The short answer
There are three kinds. Free, open-source apps that watch one or a few agents, such as Claude Island and Open Island. Paid apps that answer for many agents: Gnista and its closest rivals, Vibe Island, AgentPeek, AgentNotch, Crew Tower and Runnock. And subscriptions tied to a service, such as Pushary Isle.
If you run one agent and want it free, a free app is enough. If you run several and want to answer them without switching windows, the paid apps are the choice, and what separates them is which agents they answer, which terminals they reach, what they cost, and what they do to your setup.
Why Gnista
- It answers the most. Commands, diffs with line numbers, plans, multiple-choice questions and replies, for 12 agents, not just Allow and Deny.
- It reaches your servers. Agents on a Linux machine show up with the machine’s name, over your own ssh, and you answer them from the notch.
- It shows your limits without a sign-in. Claude Code and Codex 5-hour and weekly usage, from the agents’ own files. No Keychain, no usage endpoint.
- It is careful with your setup. Only its own entries in an agent’s config, after a backup; disconnecting removes exactly those. Hooks return in about 30 ms and never block an agent.
- It is made for teams. One shared key, MDM configuration, a security document and invoices with a VAT number. Gnista for teams.
- It runs where you do. macOS 15 or later, Apple silicon and Intel, in six languages.
Every app, at a glance
| App | Price | Agents | Answers from the notch |
|---|---|---|---|
| Gnista | €19 once | 28 | Allow, Always, Deny, questions, plans, replies |
| Vibe Island | $19.99 once | 30 | Allow, Deny, questions |
| AgentPeek | $14.99 once | 26 to 28 | Allow, Deny, questions, plans |
| AgentNotch | $9.99 once | 9 | Allow, Deny, questions |
| Crew Tower | $9.99 once | 26 | Allow, Deny, questions, plans |
| Runnock | Once, per device | 9 | Allow, Always, Deny, questions |
| Pushary Isle | $9.99 a month | 10 or more | Approve, Deny, questions |
| Open Island | Free, GPL-3.0 | 15 | Approvals for some agents |
| CodeIsland | Free, MIT | 30+ | Approve, Deny, questions |
| Claude Island | Free, Apache 2.0 | 1 (Claude Code) | Approve, Deny |
| Notchi | Free, GPL-3.0 | 2 | Not described |
| Coucou | Free, MIT code | 10+ | Allow, Deny, Always, questions |
| Chimlo | Free, GPL-3.0 | 2 | Claude Code: Allow, Deny |
One app at a time
Gnista vs Vibe Island
Vibe Island is the closest app to Gnista: paid, one-time, made for many agents, with approvals and terminal jumping. They differ in price, trial, languages, the agents each lists and how much you can answer from the notch.
Gnista vs AgentPeek
AgentPeek is a paid notch and menu bar app for Apple silicon Macs, with usage tracking and dev server management next to its approvals.
Gnista vs AgentNotch
This is the paid AgentNotch at agentnotch.app. A free app at agentnotch.com and an open-source project on GitHub share the name; they are different products.
Gnista vs Crew Tower
Crew Tower is a paid, one-time notch app for 26 agents, with approvals, plans and an optional way to send a finished Claude Code session its next prompt.
Gnista vs Runnock
Runnock is a paid, one-time notch app for nine agents. It needs macOS 26 and Apple silicon.
Gnista vs Pushary Isle
Pushary Isle is the notch part of Pushary, a service that syncs agent approvals to your phone and other devices. It is a subscription and needs a Pushary account.
Gnista vs Open Island
Open Island is free and open source (GPL-3.0), with no server, telemetry or account. Its README says it is separate from the closed-source Vibe Island.
Gnista vs CodeIsland
CodeIsland is an open-source (MIT) notch app that says it supports 30-plus coding tools, with a free iPhone and Apple Watch companion.
Gnista vs Claude Island
Claude Island is a free, open-source (Apache 2.0) menu bar app for Claude Code only.
Gnista vs Notchi
Notchi is a free, open-source (GPL-3.0) companion for Claude Code and Codex that lives in the notch of a MacBook.
Gnista vs Coucou
Coucou is a notch companion with a Mochi character. Its code is MIT; its name, character, icon and sounds are copyrighted. It also ships for Windows, Linux and Android.
Gnista vs Chimlo
Chimlo is a young, free, open-source (GPL-3.0) notch app for Codex and Claude Code. Its first public release is v0.1.0.
Questions to ask any notch app
- Which agents can I answer from the notch, and which does it only show? The two are different features.
- What does it change in my agents’ configs, and is it undone when I disconnect? Look for a backup and for entries that are its own.
- Does it read another app’s credentials, such as the Keychain, or open local ports? It should need neither.
- What happens to my agent if the app crashes or quits? Hooks should return fast and never block the agent. Gnista’s return in about 30 ms.
- What happens when the licence or the trial ends? Does the app keep working, and what stops?
- Where does my session data go? Gnista sends nothing about sessions anywhere unless you set up phone notifications or webhooks.
Gnista is not for you if
- You are on Windows or Linux, or on a Mac older than macOS 15. Agents on Linux servers do connect, over ssh.
- You use only Claude Code and want it free.
- You want it from the Mac App Store or Homebrew. Gnista is a signed, notarised download.
Facts about other apps come from their own pages and README, on the date above. Prices and features change; if something here is out of date, write to support@gnista.sh and we fix it.